I think Ina Garten, aka the Barefoot Contessa, is the queen of scones. She is also the queen of cream and butter. I have experimented with her scone recipes for a while now, and I've decided that low fat buttermilk is an acceptable substitute for heavy cream in her scone recipes. I have tried to reduce the amount of butter she uses, but quite frankly, if you reduce the amount of butter too much it changes the texture and the integrity of the scones. If you are not willing to use some butter in a recipe, don't bother making scones.
The key to making good scones is making sure butter your butter is ice cold and work quickly. As a matter of fact, your buttermilk or cream should be very cold as well. If you handle the dough too much, the heat from your hands will melt the butter and will result in dense scones. You want to see small bits of butter in your dough. This dough freezes well too. You can mix up a batch, cut them out and freeze them before you bake them. I put the cut-out scones on a pan lined with a silpat, place the pan in the freezer, and freeze for about an hour. After they are frozen, I remove them from the pan and pop them into a ziplock freezer bag and keep them for a rainy day. When you want to bake them, just pop them onto a baking sheet lined with parchment or silpat, brush with egg wash, and sprinkle with sugar. They do not need to be defrosted and take just 5 minutes longer to bake.
This recipe makes a lot of scones. I made a batch for our October staff meeting along with Pumkin Ginger Nut Muffins that can be found on Simply Recipes.
I think I ended up with 20 scones. Obviously, you can change the yield by using a different sized cutter. If you don't want 20 scones, cut the recipe in half. I usually cut the recipe in half, and still freeze half. It's a good idea to only bake as many as you will consume in a day or two.
I think I ended up with 20 scones. Obviously, you can change the yield by using a different sized cutter. If you don't want 20 scones, cut the recipe in half. I usually cut the recipe in half, and still freeze half. It's a good idea to only bake as many as you will consume in a day or two.